High Tech Thursday ― Draft One. Question One: Who wrote the first draft?

W. Matthew Dodge's avatarPosted by

[By Kyana Givens, FDP Special Counsel for Strategic Litigation & Automation]

Add one question to every case review: Who wrote the police report? Not which officer signed it. Who, or what, wrote it. The answer may change your case.

Police departments across the country now use Axon’s Draft One, a generative AI tool that “listens” to body-camera audio and writes a narrative report in seconds. The officer reviews it, fills in the brackets, and signs. Forbes reports that more than 600,000 police reports have been written with help from Axon’s AI tools.

Here is the part that should get our attention: When the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) investigated in 2025, Draft One did not save the first AI draft, and an Axon product manager said that was by design. Once the officer exported the final report, the record of what the machine wrote and what the officer wrote was gone. California now makes agencies keep that draft. Most states do not.

Courts are starting to notice. This month, a Maricopa County (Ariz.) court released a man arrested for DUI after finding it could not determine probable cause from a report written with help from an AI tool. That tool was Truleo, a Draft One competitor, which tells us the issue is bigger than one vendor. One courtroom, one ruling, but it is a signal worth hearing.

This is not a reason to despair. The same design choice that hides the draft hands us our best questions, and asking them costs us nothing but a Rule 16 letter and a little curiosity.

Closer than you think:

Draft One is not just a West Coast experiment. In our district, a city at the South end of Fulton County, Chattahoochee Hills, approved a 10-year Axon contract in August 2026, after a resident objected that the package included Draft One report writing. Florida is further along: Hillsborough County (for non-criminal calls so far), Tampa, and Palm Beach County use it, and Palm Beach deputies produced more than 3,000 AI-assisted reports in about four months. Lakeland and Crestview are next.

That matters for federal practice because so many of our clients’ cases begin with a local stop or a task force officer. These reports land in our discovery even when no federal agent ever touched the keyboard.

The federal side is quieter, but not silent. No federal agency lists Draft One by name. But in DOJ’s 2025 AI inventory, the Executive Office for U.S. Attorneys reports a deployed, high-impact generative AI use of Axon’s Evidence.com that produces “Reports, narratives, and summaries.” ATF reports using Axon’s Fusus camera network through HIDTA (High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas) partners, the federally funded task forces where local, state, and federal officers work drug cases together. The Marshals use Axon AI to transcribe and redact video, and DEA lists its body-camera AI tools as retired. An inventory line shows what an agency says it can do, not what happened in a given case. It does show us where to ask.

The rules have not caught up. Utah and California are the only states that regulate AI-assisted police reports; California now requires a disclosure on AI-assisted reports and requires agencies to keep the first draft. Georgia, Florida, and Alabama have no such law, and there is no federal statute. Some prosecutors have moved on their own. King County (Wash.) will not accept AI-assisted narratives, and Connecticut’s Chief State’s Attorney paused AI-drafted criminal reports statewide in April 2026. We have not seen a similar policy from our U.S. Attorney’s Office.

What we can do:

  • Ask early. In discovery, ask whether AI helped draft any report, affidavit, or summary, and whether Evidence.com’s AI touched what the government produced. Request the body-camera audio, transcripts, audit logs, and AI policy, and send preservation letters before they disappear.
  • Cross on authorship. Which facts did the officer see, and which did the software supply? Draft One drafts from the audio transcript, not the video.
  • Use the rules we already have. If an officer adopted a machine’s narrative, Jencks and Rule 26.2 questions follow. And you don’t have to wait for trial: Rule 12(h) applies Rule 26.2 at suppression hearings, so once the officer testifies, you can ask for their statements then. If AI touched a sworn affidavit, softened hedges or dropped facts may be Franks material.
  • Use open records. EFF has published request templates, and Axon can generate a list of an agency’s Draft One reports when asked.

Quick tells. Look for a disclosure line at the end, a leftover [bracket], a sentence that makes no sense, or a report full of dialogue but thin on what the officer saw. Then check every key phrase against the audio. Draft One is the biggest name, not the only one: Truleo and Code Four make similar tools, so ask about any AI, not just Axon. Our very own FDP one-page checklist has the rest.

A map to start from:

We also built a map to track agencies using Draft One, Truleo, or Code Four that we could confirm from public sources, and we’ve highlighted agencies within the Eleventh Circuit. [View the map here]. Before you cite it, check it. This map is a snapshot as of November 19, 2026, not a census. Agencies adopt these tools quietly, often inside body-camera contracts or free trials that never get their own vote, and some drop it just as quietly. Treat every pin as a lead, not a fact. Send the records request. Ask in discovery. Look for newer reporting. And if you find an agency we missed or one that has changed course, tell us, so the next defense attorney standing up in court has better information than we did.

Every new technology in this system has followed the same path: first quiet adoption, and then a defense attorney who asks the right question. AI report-writing is still in the quiet phase. Let’s be the ones who ask. Our clients deserve to know who, or what, wrote the story being told about them.

Additional source links:

Leave a Reply